Dealing with guests that make up stories to get a free stay

Georgia487
Level 2
Fordland, MO

Dealing with guests that make up stories to get a free stay

Hi, we recently had a couple that stayed for two nights and after leaving have requested a full refund due to a cobweb and some ridiculous things that are lies and can easily be proven untrue. They plan to give us a terrible review even though their accusations are lies because we won't refund their money. How do other owners handle these scam situations?

9 Replies 9
Karen114
Top Contributor
Bolton, MA

@Georgia487  Good morning!  My welcome message states that if there are any deficiencies noticed upon arrival or within the first 24 hours of arrival, they must be reported.  We do not refund for things not reported and not having an opportunity to correct. This seems to help. 

 

I would start crafting your response to the review now before it arrives and save it.  This way you will be crafting it while you are still relatively calm and clear headed.  You can fine tune it after the review arrives.   I use Chat GPT to help me with this.  

Karen

@Georgia487 

If the guest in any way implied they would leave a negative review in the message thread if they didn't get a refund, that would be your grounds for getting the review removed. These days, Airbnb has turned over this process to AI and it's proven abysmal and is still very difficult to get a review removed these days, even when the guest violates Airbnb written policies. 

 

I would quote the policy verbatim in your request to remove the review:

 

This review should be removed as biased as the guest attempted to coerce a refund, and threatened consequences in exchange for a positive review unless they received compensation in violation of Airbnb's Review Policy:

 

“Reviews should be unbiased

  • Members of the Airbnb community may not coerce, intimidate, extort, threaten, incentivize or manipulate another person in an attempt to influence a review, like promising compensation in exchange for a positive review or threatening consequences in the event of a negative review.”

 

Airbnb's Review Policy

https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/2673

 

Jo1044
Level 4
Durham, United Kingdom

This is an excellent advice @Joan2709, thank you for sharing! I now save a copy of your suggestion, one never know when this may come handy! Best wishes, Jo. 

Patricia2526
Top Contributor
Manila, Philippines

Hi @Georgia487 

I recommend contacting Airbnb Support immediately if a guest threatens you with a bad review in exchange for a refund. Be sure to include clear screenshots of your conversation as evidence. This kind of behavior is considered extortion and goes against Airbnb’s review policy.  


Keep all communication on the Airbnb platform so it’s properly documented.

 

Thank you. We will be contacting Air B n B today about this. We really appreciate your advice. Georgia Norman

Vera925
Level 3
Newark, NJ

Hello,

I had a similar issue — a guest left a negative review without ever bringing up concerns during their stay, and the claims were not accurate. The next guests who stayed had no issues at all, and since then I’ve continued to receive positive feedback and regular bookings.

 

Unfortunately, sometimes a review reflects more about the guest’s character or intentions than the actual experience. What helps is that future guests can see the overall pattern of good feedback from others who have stayed, which usually speaks louder than one off-base review.

Buko31
Level 2
Ikeja, Nigeria


Ugh, I’m sorry you’re going through this  it’s stressful when guests try to game the system. I’ve managed properties where this happened too, and here’s what I’ve found helps

Firstly Document everything  Keep photos of the property between cleanings, and if possible, short check-in walkthrough videos. That way, if a guest claims a cobweb or other issue, you have timestamped proof.

Secondly Keep all communication on Airbnb Never handle it outside the platform. That way, Airbnb Support can clearly see the guest’s false claims versus your proof.

 Then Don’t refund under pressure  Unless Airbnb specifically rules against you, standing firm is usually the best move. Scammy guests often hope you’ll panic and pay them off.

You should Respond professionally to reviews  If they leave something unfair, you can write a calm, factual public reply. Other potential guests will see your professionalism and ignore the false claim.

At the end of the day, most hosts deal with a guest like this at least once. The good news is that when you document well and keep communication clear, Airbnb usually sides with the host.


Hello everyone, I’m Racheal, a short-term rental co-host and property manager. I work with Airbnb hosts in the USA, Nigeria, and abroad to keep their properties fully booked, optimize listings for visibility, and handle smooth guest communication. I enjoy helping new and experienced hosts reduce stress, boost occupancy, and create amazing guest experiences.
Jo1044
Level 4
Durham, United Kingdom

Thank you for your suggestions, @Buko31 , thanks to this I've just realised I will need to improve my way of documenting the state of our property, it was a really useful tip regarding the video recordings... 

Frank2258
Level 1
Hertford, NC

Get AIRbnb involved immediately.  

More tools to help you meet your goals

Resource Center

Explore guides for hospitality, managing your listing, and growing your business.