This is what I wrote to BnB about them foisting instant book on new hosts
==================================================================================
Dear BnB
As a superhost I wanted to provide you with my views on BnB forcing new hosts to accept instant booking. It is wholly unacceptable having safety and financial implications for hosts.
If new hosts are concerned about financial fines and withholding of superhost status they may feel forced to accept unsuitable guests. As a single female I like to vet my guests carefully to ensure I feel safe and comfortable before confirming a booking and I am sure this is a key factor for others too.
I know you say you can use verification and house rules to filter guests but nothing replaces being able to chat back and forth via email to get a sense of a guest and their plans. For me and many others it's not just about house rules, but who our guests are and their plans for their visits. You can't filter this through creating house rules.
BnB should be wanting to make sure new hosts have a positive start to their BnB experience - not make it difficult for them by foisting potentially unsuitable guests upon them. Bad for the host and the guest and ultimately for your brand reputation and income.
Can you explain why you have introduced this pilot? Why you don't warn new hosts that they will be forced to use Instant Book? And why you didn't carry out research with existing hosts before it was implemented. Finally I would like to know whether you have plans to expand it.
I am sure that many hosts like myself would never have signed up to BnB if Instant Book was foisted upon us and that you will lose many thousands of superhosts if you try and implement this more widely.
I look forward to your early detailed response.