@Russell49 I agree, in that I don't like reviews where the host simply states something like "Better suited to a hotel" or " Cannot recommend". I'd like to know why, because not everything one host objects to would be objectionable to all hosts.
For instance, a guest who's unfriendly, or socially challenged, or doesn't respect the host's privacy could be a very uncomfortable situation for a home-share host, who wouldn't want to host them again, but wouldn't necessarily affect an entire place host who has self check in and almost no interaction with guests.
I at least want to know the basic nature of why a guest was objectionable- poor communication, ignoring of house rules, damages, leaving a pig sty behind them. But like I said, I don't really need all the gritty details to get the jist of the matter.
But it's fine that hosts can come to the forum and list all the transgressions of a bad guest. Gets it off the host's chest, is often quite interesting and unbelievable to read and helps other hosts to realize that they aren't alone in experiencing what they might assume is super rare behavior.