@Shannon27 I had a similar issue when I lived in NY. I lived in Harlem and work at Chelsea too. Back then, I always asked my guest what time is their arrival then I can discuss check-in process from there. I was not able to host some people because our schedule did not work out. You can always disclose the information in the listing and tell each guest before accepting their request that they need to get the key from Chelsea, if they are ok with it, then there won't be any problem. NY is a very competitive market, so as long as you can stay competitive, I think that some people will be ok with this. There is express subway anyway.