Policy on Assistance Animals

Policy on Assistance Animals

Recently, I've had two guests book my otherwise pet-excluded space with therapy animals. I was surprised at the lack of support for hosts in Airbnb's policy and would like to see this policy revised. I am an amimal lover and dog owner, and am totally supportive of the use of assistance animals; but there are issues for hosts that Airbnb's one-sided policy ignores:

 

1) That the guest doesn't have to disclose the presence of a therapy animal prior to booking.

Transparency is fundamental to trust. This is homesharing, these are not commercial spaces. It's only fair that the host is totally prepared and that any questions are resolved prior to a guest stay.

2) That the host cannot charge extra due to the presence of a tharapy animal.

This is not a only matter of how well trained the therapy animal is. The next guest may have severe allergies that, being a pet-excluded home, may not come up during the booking process. Spaces should get a "deep clean" to get rid of pet fur and dander that the therapy animal leaves behind. Airbnb may be jeopardizing the host's future guest satisfaction if the host can't afford adequate cleaning after the guest with an animal leaves.

3) That Airbnb requires no documention for assistance animals.

Any bona fide assistance animal should have documnentation that describes what services it provides and how it has beeen trained. As for Emotial Support Animals (ESA's) it's worth noting that ANY animal can be considered an ESA (birds, pigs, etc.) and it's particularly easy to get a letter or vest online. Property managers are allowed to ask for a letter from a doctor or a licensed therapist if an animal is considered an ESA.

4) Just because an animal is good with humans doesn't mean it gets along with other animals.

This should be self-explanatory, but animal-to-animal dynamics can be unpredictable and it's not fair to the host, the hosts pets or the guest's animal that unfamilar animals be foisted upon each other.

 

You need to do better on this one, Airbnb.

2 Comments
Karen641
Level 2

Excellent points.  We have a dog friendly place, but I still wouldn't be happy of someone showed up with one and we were not aware before hand.  We need to prepare for our dog guests, too, so that they feel welcomed along with their humans. 

 

And while we LOVE our own very sweet dogs, I wouldn't dream of taking them into someonelse's space unless they were absolutely welcome (therapy dog or not....and really, aren't all good dogs "therapy dogs" anyway?).  It's just a matter of respect, manners, polite behaviours, not aggravating allergic people, etc.....   Some people just really hate dog hair, and that's okay.  We have a right to make OUR house rules and when we stay in other people's homes we follow THEIR rules. 

 

Some homeowner insurance companies do not allow certain breeds, same with some landlords, and that also brings up issues here.  If someone brings a "forbidden" breed dog into your home and something happens and your homeowner's insurance doesn't cover it, who does?  Pretty rude and inconsiderate on the part of your guests, also very deceitful and untrustworthy behaviour.   I'm new to this, but it seems that the whole point of Airbnb is so that we have this ability to find places to stay that fit our unique needs and share places to stay with people who like what we offer.  I would think if you have a dog FOR WHATEVER REASON that you would search out only places where your dog is also invited.  

 

 

Rebecca181
Level 10

@Erin162 - I stumbled upon your excellent post when I was composing mine on the same subject. I posted in the 'Host' forum yesterday on this very matter. I have several concerns around the lack of host consideration when it comes to the Animal Assistant Policy - especially the Emotional Support Animal aspect, and this is what my own post addressed. I will include it here at the end of my response. I'd like to add that the fact that we are not allowed to know in advance; that we cannot ask for any kind of waiver to be signed (such as "you are responsible for fumigation charges if fleas are evident after your visit / if there is damage to the property, including furniture and carpets / if your animal damages neighboring property" etc, etc), seems most unreasonable in that it would seem that us hosts lose the rights that we have under the American Disabilities Act (ADA) in that the ADA does NOT acknowledge Emotional Support Animals as being protected under these federal laws. 

 

The other issue is that the Airbnb policy does not even define Emotional Support Animal. Therefore, a guest could show up with just about any kind of animal, and, according to Airbnb, we are supposed to accommodate it. That's not right. 

 

Here's my own post on the matter, and if you want to see the many responses I have received that favor and support a policy change, here is the link to the thread: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/Hosting/Why-I-Take-Issue-With-Airbnb-s-Policies-Around-Emotional...

 

My Post: 

I have an issue with Airbnb's policy declaring that an emotional support animal is to be treated the same as an ADA-protected animal, because as a licensed psychotherapist, I am aware that many people are able to easily convince a licensed mental health professional that they 'need' their pet to be documented / authorized as an 'emotional support animal' but the true intent is that they wish to travel anywhere with the animal and not be challenged on it. I know this first hand, as I am a licensed therapist. I have refused more than once such requests (even from a few friends and acquaintances who were not clients!) because they were not justified and it would be unethical for me to agree to such a request - but some therapists are not so diligent. Also, it is my understanding that the ADA does not recognize or protect under the law 'emotional support animals' . Here are the two 'policies' (Airbnb policy and ADA federal law):

 

Airbnb's Policies: "Emotional Support Animal: Airbnb defines assistance animals to include Emotional Support Animals. These are animals that are used as part of medical treatment and/or therapy to assist with an individual’s daily functional tasks, but are not limited to a specific type of animal and are not required to be trained to assist an individual in a particular task. These animals are sometimes referred to as comfort animals or therapy animals."

 

And this is from the ADA: 

"If you're an individual with an emotional or psychological disability- emotional support animals can be an excellent companion. While emotional support animalsare used as part of some medical treatment plans, they are not considered service animals under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).Nov 11, 2016"
 
 I therefore am concerned that Airbnb has it's own policy around this and has included emotional support animals in it's anti-discrimatory categories, even though the ADA does not. It would seem to put the host in an unfair position. I have seen some cavalier responses on other forums to hosts asking about this issue, such as, "So if the animal destroys something just take photos and collect money for it from the guest and kick them out", etc. Well, if you are booked pretty much full-time year-round like we are, with same day turnover, finding that a guest's supposed "support" animal has destroyed something in your rental a few hours before the next guest checks in, or having a guest checking in who understood your property to be a pet-free zone and they chose it in part for this reason due to allergies, etc, can put undue hardship on both the host and the guest that follows the support animal's 'visit'. I'd be curious to hear people's thoughts on this. It irks me, frankly, that Airbnb is seemingly not aligning it's policies with ADA definitions and laws. Your thoughts? By the way, please do not assume I do not enjoy animals. I in fact originally had my Cottage listed as pet-friendly, but my two large dogs and the guest dogs engaged in barking and territorial behavior despite a wall separating them and despite all dogs being relatively well behaved. The guest dogs tend to mark their 'new' territory in such cases, so this was an issue as well. As a therapist, I specialize in animal assisted therapy (horses and dogs). So this is not about my not wanting animals on my property. It is about hosts being put in an unfair position unnecessarily, given federal laws do not recognize emotional support animals as a protected animal but Airbnb does, as well as the fact that in some cases the 'emotional support' animal title and privilege is being misused / abused by both clients and licensed mental health professionals at times. Therapists whose incomes depend on accommodating their clients sometimes have trouble saying "No - that would not be ethical", particularly when they are new to the field and trying to build a clientele. There is also the matter of our not being allowed to have guests sign animal addendums or waivers, nor can we collect extra fees. In my dog addendum guests had to agree to de-flea dogs before visiting the Cottage and to pay for de-fleaing if I had to fumigate after their stay - which also would result in possible loss of income for me if guests following could not be accommodated by me.