@Caitlin35
So, she never left a review and did not make a claim either to you, or the resolution centre at the time!
Ok Caitlin, I would send back to her...."Sure, I will refund the payment for your stay on the condition that you pay me the cost of repairing the coffee table your scratched, the bed linen you carelessly ruined and had to be replaced, and the dining chair you broke, all of which I have pictures of!....The total cost of repairs was $526.00....Do we have a deal, or should I involve Airbnb"!
This turkey will disappear faster than a thanksgiving dinner, and you can then flag her profile for being a hussler!!!
Good luck girl...
Cheers.....Rob