@Marci837
Marci, when a hotel sets its tariff it builds a certain percentage into that tariff for breakages and periodic replacements. It does this on an actuarial basis. Every guest has it as part of their room cost.
We as hosts need to do the same....we are after all in the same business, why should the rules be any different for us than it is for them.
We say that Airbnb is great because we offer similar accommodation to the public at a vastly reduced rate. That is our fault not the hotels, we undersell what we offer, often cutting each others throats in a price war to compete with each other.....and in doing so not making allowances for the necessary incidental costs involved. And Airbnb love it, the cheaper the better, the more guests they attract. But that does not make Airbnb responsible, we offer it, we cover the cost of providing it!
We expect Airbnb to do that.......they don't. I would say they were possibly quite generous in offering you $25 on a carpet clean. I would have expected them to say, carpet cleaning falls under the banner of regular maintenance and not eligible for compensation.
Cheers........Rob