I'd love to share my own experience with this. Usually, my guests leave a quick review because I prompt them to do so at the airport, while they have nothing else to do. So I'd say most of the time, their review comes in a couple of hours after they leave the home.
Depending on the extent of the damage, I evaluate if I'd host them again (probably not), if I'd want business from their friends and family, also probably not. So I tend to say in my review that they were "Friendly, but better suited to (hotel, resort) environment." I've never received retaliation from saying that, but I get to warn other hosts. If the damage exceeds US30, then I send a friendly message saying that while accidents happen, we'd appreciate some compensation.
The Johnsons