Hi J.J.,
I did create my Guidebook and took a lot of time to make it as complete as possible, making multiple suggestions in each category. However, I was really disapointed to see that when you look at it on the site, there is no way for a guest to search by category such as restaurants for instance. Also, they are listed in the order that they were added which means that, since I have 30 options, people would have to scroll through all of them to find all the restaurant suggestions I have.
I have since created my own which I have put in a binder with tabs separating Food Scene from Sightseeing or Essentials, so guests can go to the section they want. I also categorized the type of restaurants, whether breakfast or upscale, French or Greek, etc. They are also a full letter page with pictures, a map from my place, showing distance and walking time (from Google), their phone number in case guests want to call to make a reservation as well as their web site, plus of course, my description and comments about the place. All my guests have raved about it and none of them had ever looked at the one on the site.
It would have been nice to be able to send it to guests after they had booked but it looks so awful when trying to print it or make a pdf that it would not be very useful.
In the beginning I would ask my guests if they had looked at my guidebook in my listing and most of them did not even know what I was talking about, so I doubt very much that they would look at the Guidebook before booking . It's unfortunate because it is a great idea but, in my opinion, badly executed.