Looking at Joe's listing, it's from the guest called Dante I presume.
Dante gave a one line review ' Was a nice place and stay. Around a lot in Wicker Park area'
Joe's review on Dante noted that he was a first time user of airbnb but expressed disappointment with his group's conduct and pointed out the damages found after departure.
Dante then made a public response to Joe's review on his group, Dante's Inferno if you wish, to say in summary he - didn't do it.
Well, for Joe, everything is in order on your listing, Dante's reponse to your review only appears on his own page and would only be seen by your potential guests if they were drilling down on every visitor. So the chances of that happening are slim.
Good for you to leave an honest and candid review. Future hosts can make their own mind up in future on Dante.