@Denise1112 forget for a moment about what Airbnb's algorithm deems a "Superhost," as it would rather have you be a doormat to your guests to keep your ratings up than enforce your rules and protect your home. Instead, consider the qualities that command respect from guests and attract the best ones - indeed, those who leave you the better ratings.
A truly super host would have measures in place to prevent parties before they can get to the point that neighbors complain. That includes a clear, ironclad set of rules against unregistered visitors, without loopholes and wiggle room, and a plan to use the information your existing features are already picking up quickly and efficiently. From the hosting community's perspective a super host would have reviewed all of the guests who threw parties too. And these days, being super at hosting also means being able to prevent or resolve independently any issues that might have involved customer service back when it existed.
It's ridiculous that the bar for entry into this phony "elite" can be as little as 10 short bookings. A newer host could have a wonderfully appointed home and great hospitality skills, but still a lot to learn about how to anticipate the common issues and expectations specific to Airbnb. It would be nice to see more encouragement to ascend the learning curve, rather than premature laurels to rest on.
Anyway, if you're invested in keeping that cluster of orange pixels, your best tactic will be to not use instant book, and engage each request with a bit of dialogue to make sure the expectations are completely accurate. Over time it becomes bizarrely easy to predict which guests will be problematic within the original correspondence, and when you weed those out (and continue doing everything else well) youare far likelier to get consistent 5 star ratings.
