If you can do long term and make roughly the same then only a crazy person would do Airbnb. I have both a long term and STR, and the STR is a daily annoyance of cleaning, reviews, smoking, garbage, bad parking, guest communication etc etc. Why would you want it ?
I think the best STR is a part of a house (MIL etc) where it is hard to rent separately and you can keep a close eye on it and be around. Your total cost is low, expenses are already those that you have, so risk is low.
An STR should make maybe two or three times stand alone rent, but only up to a point. A neighbour had a house that would rent for $4k / month - doing that alone on Airbnb would be difficult and highly seasonal. He wasted about 6 months before renting it out long term.