For the sake of total transparency... As promised, here's what I sent to AirBnb Help the other day, and their response is in the Reply right under this:
-------
Hi [ABB rep's name] - thanks for answering these questions the other day. They were very helpful, and I appreciate it very much. Your answers bring up two follow-up questions/concerns I have, if that's aright. I'm not trying to be difficult... I think I'm just trying to express how I and other hosts might see some of the Plus program's snags from our perspective, and to try and get them cleared up as best as possible:
1) How is the acceptance rate for AirBnb Plus determined? I know this may seem like a simple question, but just to be 100% sure... is it only for the instances in the previous 365-days where we actually clicked "Decline" for a Booking Request? Are there any other factors or actions at all that would affect the acceptance rate metric?
2) When I see Help articles like this one (https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/360/can-i-decline-booking-inquires-or-reservation-requests), which is what Hosts have been working off of, why is there no mention that declining requests actually could impact us to be exluded from special programs? To be totally transparent, it's not a secret that not being a part of Plus is a negative in many respects because --even as it says on AirBnb's main Plus Hosting page-- Plus listings receive, "Elevated placement and increased visibility in search results." This is important for hosts in order to generate revenue...
So, my question is: Why is the 95% acceptance rate considered a metric for this program, in light of the fact that AirBnb has never said that it could be a linch pin for hosts not being able to take part on programs that give them better rankings, thus more visibility and thus more potential revenue?
If a host is just declining people all the time, I can understand how your algorithym might start to move them down the rankings, as this Help article suggests: (https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/39/what-factors-determine-how-my-listing-appears-in-search-resul...). However, like that same article says, "Occasionally rejections are necessary," but in the case of Plus, this could dramatically impact someone's ability to take part in the Plus program for a year or longer (which we weren't made aware of until now).
This seems like AirBnb has been saying one thing, yet planning something else behind the curtain. I mean, if you are looking for "truly exceptional" hosts [NOTE: "truly exceptional" was what the ABB rep used to describe their ideal Plus Hosts], that sometimes means knowing when someone is going to be a bad guest, or when someone looking to book your listing is really from a marketing company or something like that. There could be a million reasons why it makes sense to decline a booking request, and the best AirBnb hosts know that simply letting everyone into their home is not a sign of their exceptionality.
I'm looking forward to hearing more from you about these questions/concerns, and thanks again for taking the time to help with this!
--------
ABB's response is below in the reply...