@Cheri2
Well to be honest Cheri, you are a victim of your location!
"We are tucked in on the Perry Oldenburg Wildlife Preserve 400 or so acres. The end of the road 1/2 mile is the Withlacoochee State Forest and River. One hour from Tampa, Orlando, Ocala, Homosassa, and 30 minutes from the gulf."
You promote your listing as a place to unwind and enjoy nature and that is exactly what you are getting....people who don't want to be somewhere other than there.
There is an expectation that when somebody books your listing, and pays for it, for a 'block' of time, they have the right to use it for that period, be it day or night.
My personal feeling is Cheri, if you promote your listing as a retreat....horses, chooks, tortoises, lots of trees, and you turn around and tell guests they are not welcome to enjoy those treats during daylight hours your enquiry rate will fall into a black hole.
Rather than promote your listing with description and photos of all these 'goodies' you should just promote it as an overnight cabin, a stopover point to get from one glitzy location to another where people just sleep and move on!
You really can't have it both ways!!
Cheers.....Rob