@Michael & Dru, only the overall rating will affect your Superhost status. Your cottages are beautiful. As you keep getting more and more reviews I think you will find that 4 star ratings are far and few between. I had this blurb added to my welcome binder (many other hosts here have something similar.) I have been very pleased with all my reviews after adding this. You may want to consider something with an emphasis on value.
Regarding your review following your stay in our Airbnb
Please note that the 5 star rating system is NOT like a ‘hotel’ rating system:
As Airbnb ‘Super Hosts’ we do all we can to ensure that our property meets your expectations, as based on our listing description, photos, and reviews. A 5 star (super) host is one who consistently gives their guests what they promise. Guests who rate their hosts with 5 stars for the ‘Overall Experience’ category are saying they were happy with their stay and want future guests to know it. Reading the reviews of previous guests will help potential future guests feel confident in their stay. Therefore, please let us know if you are disappointed or dissatisfied with your stay or any aspect of your stay while you are still here so we have a chance to address the issue and ensure that your stay is a ‘5 Star’ experience, and all you hoped it would be. *When rating us on your ‘Overall Experience’, we only ask that you remember that we cannot control our location or the weather!"