@Christopher2258 Guests have gotten much more entitled and uncaring over the years, so guests taking items that have been left as a courtesy or making off with the supplies that make your property a stand-out is annoying and becoming more frequent.
AirBnB is review driven, and one thing that you have to concern yourself with is at what price point or degree of aggravation do you request that the guest who has left reimburse you for damages or the taking of supplies. Guests are quick to take offense when asked for payment and will probably retaliate by leaving a nasty review. You don't want to lose your marketability; be careful in your actions.
My price point for damages and annoyances is about $50. Guests have taken the extra rolls of toilet paper and the laundry detergent -- one guest made off with an omelet pan and the dish drainer. I allocate $2 of my earnings per booking to a replacement petty cash fund that takes care of these unexpected expenses. Yes, it "penalizes" the good guest and reduces my income, but having this fund keeps me sane when that entitled boor takes advantage.
Your review of the thieving guest may be simple -- "I do not recommend them as a guest". No details or further explanation given.
