@Chase109 I just think it would have been good to warn future potential guests about what happened.
Thefts are pretty common in my town, as it's a very touristy place. Most hosts of entire places here provide safes in their listings. Usually the guest can program the code themselves. There is also a "master code" that only the host or the property manager would have.
Personally, I would never leave anything of great value, whether monetary or sentimental, in a hotel room or Airbnb unless I was assured of a safe place to stash stuff. Money, credit cards, phones, jewelry, is best kept with you if there isn't any secure lock-up.
I looked through a few pages of reviews for that hotel, and while they are overwhelmingly positive, there are a few that mention bait and switch- the room they were given was not the one they booked that was pictured. I'd be wary of booking a place like that.