@Mark116
If you are able to report back RE what the new review process looks like from the guest end, that would be really helpful. If you can take screenshots, even better!
I can see there is a lot of confusion here as Airbnb has been really vague about this (intentionally, I am sure), so we are still guessing about a lot of it at this stage...
I know I was being naive/wishful, but when I heard that Airbnb was revising the review process, I was led to believe that it was in order to make things better for hosts and also that there might be a revision to the Superhost requirements, i.e. that they would go back to requiring 80% 5* reviews instead of 4.8*.
Instead, we get the chance to select from specific options to give detail about what the guest could have done better. Okay, that might be useful, but we could already state those things in the review if we wanted, e.g. guest checked out late. At the same time, guests can make additional comments about the listing, which seems fair, but not when it's stupid things like whether the check in was flexible or not, as if that was an actual REQUIREMENT for hosts. And, at the same time, they've taken away the ability for us to specify whether we would host that guest again or not, and the IB filter for recommended by other hosts.
It seems that Airbnb gives from one hand, but takes three times as much back from the other...