Hi, I'm rounding the corner on my first year of hosting and have generally had a positive experience. I've had almost no problems with anyone.
I just had a booking for a weekend though, one of my guests smoked marijuana in one of the bedrooms. There is a no smoking inside policy and there is a private backyard and garden where one could step outside and smoke. My house manual encourages them to do so, if they are smokers.
Otherwise, the guests were not troublesome, did not damage the place and were not unusually dirty or anything like that. Since it was marijuana, the smell has aired out pretty well, but there was just enough smell and some residue in the room from the marijuana grinder that I knew what occurred. I'm not sure how to review this guest. I don't think they deserve 5-stars for "respected house rules", but since there wasn't damage and there weren't any other problems. On the other hand, I don't want to trigger a negative review of my place - there really wasn't any harm or sufficient damage done for me to need to pursue compensation - the room just needed to air out (luckily there wasn't a back-to-back booking).
Obviously, I can't take a picture of a smell and really prove anything, but still, the guest unnecessarily violated a house rule. I just wondered how other hosts handle a review for someone like this, or if I have to ignore the whole thing and emphasize I don't want smoking inside the unit in the future.