Hi, Steve,
That's so interesting that your map immediately filters down to St. Croix, because, unfortunately, whenever I or my family/friends - who all live in several different states in the United States - choose that suggestion from the list (yes, we do get that same list of suggestions when we start to type "St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands") or just type the whole phrase in manually, our map still shows pins all over the world, and our search results are still filled with listings from all over the world (even the first page of results is mostly Europe; so strange!).
I should also clarify that this problem is worst on the full Airbnb website's desktop version, whereas the mobile app on the phone and iPad seem to be slighly more accurate (not as many geographically inaccurate listings to sift through, sometimes does actually show my listing but not always, often shows the map feature correctly, etc.). But the app will sometimes only show my listing if filters are applied (such as a narrow price range).
I truly appreciate your kindness in looking into this for me and sending a screen shot! And I'm glad to know that others in the world do find St. Croix's listings more easily! Perhaps there is some odd glitch or an algorithm issue . . .
Thank you!
Stacy