Guys from my search there are 3 possibilities,
I tried 'to book' 3-10 December and it shows:
* Tyrone, Ga > 1,000 results
* Tyrone Galloway 45 Results
* Tyrone, N. Ireland 75 results
You are in 1st one [Atalanta] and
It seems to be a penalty for having 2 Airbnbs in the same town. [OP]
No, but usually Airbnb algo 'gives a little priority/ boost' to new listing for a little while
Once I was told by some very experiences on 'these things' if you want to look for your LISTING 'log out, delete cookies etc' and it makes sense, maybe best idea would be to do a search from someone else's device/ IP address and then see what is going on.
also,and here i'm not sure, I know that one can do multiple listing for same PROPERTY [say a flat and a room] since you have UNITS at same location, is this possible? Then you keep ranking for both...