Hello @Dawn241 ,
When I started a year ago, I considered implementing a tip box but ultimately decided against it for a couple of reasons.
Firstly, the effectiveness of a tip box as a source of income is limited. Unlike restaurants, which benefit from a high volume of transactions, a tip box in accommodation settings is unlikely to generate significant financial impact. Instead, you might consider incorporating a small increase in your nightly rate, such as an additional dollar, to cover any additional expenses, including mailing costs.
Secondly, while the tip box is a thoughtful gesture, it can sometimes be perceived as a request for reciprocation rather than a genuine act of generosity. True generosity, as you exemplify with the thoughtful amenities you provide (including the pretzels!), does not seek anything in return. Some guests may respond positively, but others might not be as receptive to the idea of tipping. I find that generosity, particularly in the form of time and attention, often yields positive reviews.
In summary, if you choose to try a tip jar, it’s important to manage your expectations and not take it personally if it doesn’t receive much use or only collects small amounts.
On the other hand, maybe my theory is wrong, and people here are making loads of money with tip jars. If that’s the case, I might implement one too! 🙂