@Kerry404 This is the most recent review I see you left "Becky and her family were easy guests to host. Communication was very good."
Now when I read that, I have every reason to think these were good guests I have no reason to be wary of. You have said nothing about them not leaving the place clean.
Your written review needs to align with the star ratings you give. Only hosts who use Instant Book can see star ratings. Those of us who require Requests have only the written reviews to go on. So don't be one of those hosts who leaves nice reviews and leads other hosts astray, like the previous hosts of your bad guests did to you. If you feel a guest deserves 3 stars for cleanliness, you need to mention that they left the place dirty in the written review.
Yes, it's a big learning curve- waiting to leave the review until after you've had a chance to thoroughly inspect the place is important. You might not even notice something missing or broken until you get it all cleaned and ready for the next guest, but you have 14 days to review, so no rush.
For a guest like the one whose dog chewed the seat, the review should say something like, "Guest's dog chewed a seat cushion, but the guest offered to and did pay for the damage".
This tells other hosts that they have a dog who chews things (I've had dogs all my life and they have never chewed anything but the bones I've given them) but gives them credit for being responsible about it.