FYI hosts, run your own background checks- Airbnb’s ‘checks’ not accurate

Jess78
Level 10
Eugene, OR

FYI hosts, run your own background checks- Airbnb’s ‘checks’ not accurate

Hello everyone,

I’ve been through an ordeal this past week, details of which are in another thread that I won’t launch into here, but you can certainly search for it if you’re interested.

 

i had a guest that left and I discovered lots of illegal drug use, possible manufacturing, in my home. This was NOT just pot, which is legal here in Oregon. 

 

The result of a lotof grief with Airbnb about this over the past week is this: 

-I Ran my own background check and I found criminal activity in August of 2015 that was not a traffic offense 

-no contact from the Trust and Safety team, despite 3 promises that they would contact me.

-i received $50.oo in damages due to the ‘odor’ left and nothing else

-I consulted with a hazmat team and followed their instructions,  it there was no advice or contact from Airbnb concerning guest health and safety or my home’s safety. NONE!!!

- no help from Airbnb in getting the drug criminal removed from using this service— he Is probably staying in someone else’s home right now. They said they ‘flagged’ him which only internal employees can see, not potential hosts. Again, HE HAS A CRIMINAL HISTORY and is known to have injected drugs in his body in a host’s home and he is still out and about on this site. 

 

The local cal news has been contacted about this, even though I hate to do that. All I wanted was a little support from trust and safety and I got absolutely nothing. And now other users of this site are at risk. 

 

Delisting my two properties as soon as it’s possible and I would recommend the same to others.

 

 

 

63 Replies 63

This isn't true. You are allowed to require a guest to give you their first and last names before booking. I just called airbnb and confirmed this yesterday. Please edit/update your response to not spread disinformation. 

Pete28
Level 10
Seattle, WA

Given the risks I do my best to limit the danger to my family and property

 

- make it clear we live on the property 

- always meet the guest, ideally when they arrive

- the MIL is separate and has two locked doors between us and them, 

- has a motion detector on the suite door which gives me some indication of number of 'visitors'. This has been invaluable in intercepting extra guests and dubious characters coming to 'hang out'

- at first sign of vaping, smoking, loud noise, partying appear at the suite door and suggest they find a bar etc.

 

Yeah I guess a nice lesson is that meeting the guest is paramount to safety, Pete. Although, I can't think of an instance when I would have met a guest and wanted to cancel their reservation just from shaking their hand -- you never know how they'll be as a guest. And I don't even know if Airbnb would allow that to happen either, without some big hosting penalities. 

But meeting them does make them more aware of your presence and perhaps keep them more in line. I don't think I could have stopped this guest from doing what he was going to to a

I have met plenty who I visit on a bi- daily basis - last weekend party of 3 back packers appeared to be snorting coke. Found a good excuse to drop in a few times to say hi and discuss when they were going to leave while delivering complimentary bottled water...

 

- I find a 5min chat can quickly provide evidence of any unhinged plans.

- Even looking at bags,packing, car etc helps. Lack of bags, lots of carriers, lots of cheap bags.

- Weird stuff in trash like shoes. Lots of trash. Bottles full of cigs.

- Crappy car, problems possible.

- Group of singles more likely to go nuts than a couple.

- Extra people showing up distinct red alert - wait 10mins, go down to bring some more extra bottles of water etc. Nice to meet you all...

- Locals earn bonus visits. I might even supply popcorn with the extra bottled water...

 

I think it can be managed, but sometimes we don't go out of town or too far away if I have my doubts. Bottle water is cheap at Costco. Weird way to make $$..

@Jess0, I never thought Airbnb even did background checks.

Airbnb does background checks?

 

 

I had the same assumption as @Michael0  . All you need is an email, cell phone and gov ID to join and wouldn't expect a booking site to do background checks on users.

Right, just so everyone is clear they absolutely don’t do background checks. 

 

And when hen I reported this person, a week later a CS rep contacted me and said they did a background check on him . They obviously did not, or they did and continue to allow criminals and don’t care. It is flagrantly negligent. 

 

 

Jess-great info.  So sorry what you went through.  Scarey.   

 

I will start using checkmate.

But is there a way to be sure that only people who have provided govt ID and selfies that match to Airbnb?

 

Also, does AIRBNB allow the full names to be transmitted by their email system (I kniow they black out phone numbers)

Can anyone send a photo of themselves or better yet, their ID through AIRBNB email?

And can the guests sensd their home adresses via AIRBNB email? The address  will help confirm the identity.

 

from their Trust and Safety page:

" For hosts and guests in the United States, we also conduct background checks."

https://www.airbnb.com/trust

 

So, it doesn't say there that they conduct background checks on all hosts or guests, just that they do. Sometimes. Occasionally. Maybe. Randomly? I've heard that they do random ones. Either way, I believe their statement to be misleading and it should be changed to reflect what their actual practices are.

Also this from their help pages:

"Does Airbnb perform background checks on members?

If we have enough information (usually at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth) to identify a guest or host who lives in the United States, we check certain databases of public state and county criminal records, as well as state and national sex offender registries for criminal convictions and sex offender registrations. If we have enough information (usually at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth) to identify a guest or host who lives outside the United States, we may, to the extent permitted by applicable laws and to the extent available, obtain the local version of background or registered sex offender checks.

We also check the OFAC list (which includes terrorist designations) for all users that transact on the platform. Background checks are conducted for us by our approved background check providers.

Although background checks may help identify past criminal conduct where records are available, background checks don’t always identify a person’s past crimes or other red flags, they are never a guarantee that a person won’t break the law in the future. Due to the way certain databases are maintained, there may be gaps in the coverage provided by public records searches, and the online databases may be only updated periodically by local governments which we do not control or direct. Results of these database checks may not reveal or include include recent criminal record activity.

No background check should ever be relied upon as the sole indicator of suitability. You should always exercise your own judgment about whom to interact with and follow other sensible safety tips.

How does Airbnb conduct background checks?

As discussed above, we currently check certain databases of public state and county criminal records, as well as state and national sex offender registries on U.S.-based guests and hosts where we have at least an accurate first and last name plus date of birth. If we have that information, we submit it to one of our approved background check providers, which checks the user’s identity against public records of convictions and sex offender registries.

If we have enough information (usually at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth, and government-issued ID number where applicable) to identify a guest or host who lives outside the United States, we may, to the extent permitted by applicable laws and to the extent available, obtain the local version of background or registered sex offender checks. To the extent we do this outside the United States, we will use one of our approved vendors, which checks the user’s identity against available local databases.

We also check the OFAC list (which includes terrorist designations) for all users that transact on the platform.

What are some of the limitations of these background checks?

Although background checks may help us identify past criminal conduct where records are available, they have several limitations, and do not guarantee that all past criminal conduct has been identified or that a person won’t break the law in the future. For example:

A. The scope of our search is limited

We only run these checks on U.S.-based guests and hosts when we have at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth. We do not have these identifiers for all hosts and guests and therefore cannot guarantee that we have conducted a check on every host or guest. In addition, we are not conducting these checks on additional guests staying with the guest who books an accommodation. In this case, only the guest who books that accommodation will be checked as part of that booking, when we have the necessary information.

Even where we have the necessary information, these checks only work where the users have accurately given us their full, correct legal name and date of birth. Likewise, we cannot guarantee that users who provided us full information gave us information that is accurate or belongs to them.

While we aim to refresh these checks periodically for active users, we may conduct these checks only once per user, and a check may have been conducted months before your interaction with the user.

In addition, for users who live in the United States, we do not always check every state and county courthouse records and other criminal registries or other public databases (such as but not limited to Moving Violation Reports (MVRs) and Driving Records). It's important to know that the criminal record information searched and reported for each type of check varies by state, and sometimes county, due to variations in state laws and state and county criminal record reporting systems.

Lastly, because of differences in foreign laws, language, and the manner in which foreign records are maintained and reported, we may not run background checks on users located outside the United States, and even if we do, the scope and accuracy of coverage may vary.

B. Search results may be incomplete

The databases we check are not necessarily complete, and may not include records of prior criminal conduct. For example, not all criminal records are public in all states, not all criminal records are captured by the databases we check, and convictions and records of crimes committed outside the country where the background check is conducted may not be included. Also, as determined by applicable law, public records databases may be limited to records of conduct that took place a certain number of years prior to the date of the check (for example, the prior seven years in certain U.S. states). We cannot guarantee that the limited background checks we conduct will identify all past criminal convictions or sex offender registrations by a guest or host. Therefore, you should not rely on another user’s completion of a background check as a guarantee that the user has no criminal background or other red flags.

Finally, criminals may circumvent even the most sophisticated database or search technology.

C. Search results do not guarantee safety

In sum, while we hope these user vetting tools will be useful to help protect our community, they don’t always identify a person’s past crimes or other red flags, cannot guarantee that a person won’t break the law in the future, and are never a guarantee of safety or that a host or guest who has completed a background check is safe or safer than any unknown person you may meet in any other way.

You should also not rely on background checks as a replacement for exercising your own judgment about whom to interact with or as a replacement for following sensible safety tips.

What are the crimes for which you remove users from the platform?

We will remove users if our checks show convictions for the following:

  • A violent crime
  • Certain sexual offenses, including serious sex offenses and prostitution
  • Felony drug-related offense
  • Certain fraud and dishonesty offenses, including identity theft
  • Certain theft offenses
  • Offenses involving certain types of property damage
  • Certain invasion of privacy offenses
Huma0
Level 10
London, United Kingdom

 

Why wouldn't they have a user's first name, last name and date of birth? I would have thought this was basic information that a user had to provide (not very difficult for Airbnb to specify this as compulsory). That is worrying.

 

Or, maybe it means if they have the correct information. People could lie or use fake IDs for verification...

Airbnb states they do background checks,  but clearly they are very limited.  I suspect they do very basic internet search if they really do anything at all.   None of those would have protected poor Jennifer from the above posting.  Here's what I copied from Airbnb about back ground checks: 

Does Airbnb perform background checks on members?

If we have enough information (usually at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth) to identify a guest or host who lives in the United States, we check certain databases of public state and county criminal records, as well as state and national sex offender registries for criminal convictions and sex offender registrations. If we have enough information (usually at least the user’s first and last name plus date of birth) to identify a guest or host who lives outside the United States, we may, to the extent permitted by applicable laws and to the extent available, obtain the local version of background or registered sex offender checks.

We also check the OFAC list (which includes terrorist designations) for all users that transact on the platform. Background checks are conducted for us by our approved background check providers.

Although background checks may help identify past criminal conduct where records are available, background checks don’t always identify a person’s past crimes or other red flags, they are never a guarantee that a person won’t break the law in the future. Due to the way certain databases are maintained, there may be gaps in the coverage provided by public records searches, and the online databases may be only updated periodically by local governments which we do not control or direct. Results of these database checks may not reveal or include include recent criminal record activity.

No background check should ever be relied upon as the sole indicator of suitability. You should always exercise your own judgment about whom to interact with and follow other sensible safety tips. ...

They state they do some kind of background checks ...

They don't. We went through a similar ordeal and because we discovered our horrible guests' real names - they stupidly had mail sent to our address - we found their arrest records including multiple drug and fraud charges, and over a year of PRISON TIME in under 5 minutes. Without even running a paid background check.

Rebecca160
Level 10
Albuquerque, NM

 

Dang! still cannot tag!

 

Please read  Jess’s original posting about this very bad guest and Airbnb ‘s very wrong response, then this post will make sense. And it will also scare you. What would you do if a guest set up a drug lab, such as a portable meth lab in your rental? What do you suppose Airbnb would about damages caused by such a thing? 

 

Before i I joined Airbnb, I was soothed that Airbnb would support the host in the event of a horrible guest experience, such as a mobile meth lab or underage drinking party or any number of crazy scenarios. That does not seem to be the case nowadays.