So's here's how it played out....
We went to an Insurance broker who sells several company's policies. They've been getting more and more people who are being dumped by State Farm for all kinds of reasons. She wasn't surprised that they didn't do more to help. She had me forward the Host Guarantee and Host Protection Guarantee to provide to any underwriter's who asked. ERIE INSURANCE took care of our entire homeowner policy (cheaper than State Farm for more coverage) and added and "incidental business" rider on it for a whopping $21/year. All told, we now have more coverage at a lower price and what seems to be a thankful company that we've chosen to do business with them. Plus, the broker made it easy as pie to switch.
Anyone in the North Carolina area looking to work with our broker - PM me and I'll send you the contact details. (I'd post it here but I think the moderators will block it).