Like @Lawrene0 I do not live in a touresty area. Many of our stays are 1-2 nighters passing through to get from point A to point B, short term contract workers, conference goers or the occasional wedding attender. We are a little off the beaten path to most other Airbnb's in the area. So our guest tend to be more intentional in what they are looking for in a stay. I've seen a lot of local Airbnb's come and go in the short time we have been hosting. I can pretty much guess which ones won't be around for very long.
Some of the things I look at when looking at other local hosts pages are:
1. Nightly prices to similar set ups. We are an in-house host.
2. Their House Rules or should I lack there of. This tells me just how much thought and research they have or have not put into deciding to host.
3. How far from us they are and what side of town they are on should I need to refer a guest to another Airbnb that would better meet their needs, based on questions they ask during an inquiry.
4. Their reviews. I have actually declined a couple potential guests based on not so favorable reviews left by other local hosts for guests who frequent the area and have stayed at several Airbnbs.
“It’s not where you go, it’s who you meet along the way.” Wizard of Oz