@Jeff2253
Considering you have 4 other reviews I assume you know the review system is blind, thus meaning that your 4 star review had no affect on the way in which the host reviewed you, because they would not have seen it till you both submitted reviews or the review period (14 days) passed.
That being said, nothing in their review of you violates any policies. It is essentially a he said she said as to what happened. While I can understand your frustration if in fact the claims are false, it's hard to prove that. While you can request Airbnb to remove the review, I really doubt they will. Stating things like their sofa was beige vs white doesn't mean much. Dog poop on a beige sofa is still dog poop on a sofa.
That being said, you should always take into consideration your response. A response to a negative review is an opportunity to politely state your case and should be done so in a short and concise manner. Like @Anonymous said, your response makes you look worse. As a host I likely would have overlooked the negative review as a one off, considering you had multiple other positive reviews. However, you present as angry and overly defensive in your response. You resort to projecting blame on the host by bringing up a multitude of other issues vs just responding to what the host brought forth as a concern, which is the dog poop. This in and of itself would make me think twice about hosting you.
At this point I would just move on.
