The playing field needs to be leveled at the moment its heavly weighted in favour of the guest while the host takes all the risks with property and pocessions and Airbnb gets their fee regardless.
I applaud you Rebecca this is an outstanding idea and needs to be implement fast.
I wrote an honest review of a guest and she wrote a glowing review of my apartment only to have her email me saying she was appalled at my review of her and that she was going to call airbnb to have her review of me changed, Apprently she gave me a glowing review because she did not want to "kill my bussiness". you see the power these type of guest think they have.
I was supposed to turn a blind eye to the fact they had an additional guest that was looking for somewhere else to stay but at 19:30 on the day he was supposed to checkout at 12:00 noon was going out on the town with his friends and I was not supposed to allude to this in my review of her.
I have no dougbt that other host have been placed in a similar situation and felt black mailed into giving a bland review of their guests in order to avoid this type of backlash.