@Lizzie In addition to @Sarah's suggestion, above (Corporate getting our feedback *before* making a significant change to the platform and/or practices that will affect all hosts / super hosts, such as this incomprehensibly long, new and definitely not improved review process), it seems to me that there needs to be accountability built into the Host / Guest / Airbnb Corporate relationship - a triangular relationship that, when not working well, becomes something akin to the 'Bermuda Triangle' - with hosts feeling like their voices and their expressed concerns disappear into some mysterious, black void.
I can only wonder: Why does a company that stresses community operate in such a 'top down' manner that suggests a deliberate arrogance toward, and a possible disdain for, the very people the company built it's business on? Not to mention things like hosts having their chosen Cancellation Policy completely ignored in favor of a guest's demand for a full refund, even when undeserved. You know, things like that.
When experienced, proven hosts present the same issues over and over and over and over again ad nauseum here in the CC, clearly these would seem to warrant dedicated attention from Corporate. A dialogue should then be opened between Corporate and hosts and guests, as needed, here in the CC via a mod post, until these issues are at least somewhat (even if imperfectly) resolved.
Until this happens, the CC is merely a place for hosts to help each other out and sometimes 'vent' and 'rant', while the mods post on benign topics of interest that seem designed to transcend, ignore, and completely bypass all of the 'messiness' below. I don't know about others, but I find it all to be a bit surreal, myself...