NYC airbnb wich hunt or help?

NYC airbnb wich hunt or help?

Hi Airbnb people.

I got an enquire from this guy who lives in NYC

https://www.airbnb.com/users/show/3312247

He has many traveling and hosting reviews, and his inquiry says: 

 

"Hi Charly,Can you please confirm that your rental is legal as you dont seem to own the place?

Can you please verify that (number of the building) is. Legal rental building?

Kind thanks! "

 

my questions are:

why does he need to know about legality? specially if aparently he rents an aparment in NYC also

how does he know if I own or not the aparment?

how does he has the building number if he hasnt book?

 

I didnt reply yet, if anybody has an opinion I would like to hear it?

should I question him or just deny the booking?

 

its a pretty

 

 

 

8 Replies 8
Branka-and-Silvia0
Level 10
Zagreb, Croatia

@Charly14 yes, it is weard... but just by looking your estimate location and photos and by using google maps or going to the location he was maybe able to guess in which building your apartment is. Maybe some of his friends stayed at your place previously.. who knows...

why don't you ask him what you just asked us ? And you may also ask him does he owns the place he is renting and is it legal ? 🙂

Marzena4
Level 10
Kraków, Poland

He doesn't have any listing at the moment, @Charly14, but has reviews from guests so either his was suspended or he had to delete it, and now is trying to take some kind of revenge on other hosts? Or got employed by some authorities. Or maybe is on a mission to get NY rid of Airbnb hosts? Whatever the reason, I wouldn't trust him. 

// "The only person you can trust is yourself"

I think that is the case, and he was kiked out and trying to get revenge of other on other hosts

 

David126
Level 10
Como, CO

I assume his listing was closed down for not being legal, who knows?

David

I think that is the case

Rene-and-Zac0
Level 10
La Quinta, CA

@Charly14 What do you have to lose and is your listing legit? If your listing is legit, you have nothing to worry about but if you’re “riding dirty”, I’d leave that little nugget alone. 

Anyone that plays games like that is up to something.

As a guest, why would I care if you actually owned the listing? That’s suspect. 

 

‘You know it’s hard out here for a Host’

They don't tell you that even if you live there, you are still a hotel and that is illegal especially if you do not have sprinklers, a wired fire alarm system and secondary egress. 

 

The articles pretend it is about the "evil" hotel industry not letting guests save money instead of emphasizing the safety issues - this makes all hosts look bad by design - that we are so greedy that we would put safety behind illegal hosting.  I have stopped hosting and have found it impossible to find a roommate so I am very worried but it doesn't change the fact that I can never host again in this building because of the lack of safety elements.   Also, Inspector Chung said I would still be a hotel if I had monthly roommates unless they were on a lease.  That is terrible news and contradicts what they tell us in the press about having roommates who are not on the lease. 

 

I am not trying to ruin hosting but I personally cannot do it since the FDNY Inspector Brown said gently and sadly, "It is about safety"  - it's like someone telling you not to drive drunk and not risk killing three babies.   How can you argue with that?

I think some of the condo owners in NYC can legally host because their newer buildings have those safety elements so airbnb hosting belongs to those few hosts.  But a house probably does not have a sprinkler system.


I think NYC is hypocritical and is intentionally not going after every host because there is a benefit to the real estate industry.  I want airbnb to stay because I need the exposure to find subtenants and roommates who want to be on the lease because the other options are no good.   Not only should all hosts register but all GUESTS identities should be filed with NYPD.    I don't see the problem for airbnb letting the city do this since airbnb has already agreed to it in other cities.    It's not a big deal for airbnb to allow it. 

 

There are so many microaggressions BY GUESTS who are in your HOME and basically know that you are so desperate financially that you would actually let some stranger into your home.  

Sarah977
Level 10
Sayulita, Mexico

While this may indeed be revenge or he's employed to scout out illegal rentals, I could also see the possibilty of a guest wanting to know if the rental is legal simply to ensure that their stay would not be distrupted or terminated by the actual homeowner or authorities if the host does not have permission from owner to airbnb out the space.

There are more and more cases of long-term tenants (not airbnb guests) thinking it is okay to rent out rooms, a house, or an apartment who have not asked permission to do this. There is some widespread misconception that just because you rent a place it is yours to do whatever you want in. It is extremely rude, not to mention illegal, to think it's acceptable to turn a profit on someone else's investment without their approval.

As a homeowner (and airbnb host) I have chosen long.term tenants (not airbnbers) based upon their references, the vibe I get from them, their ability to come up with damage deposit up front, the stability of their employment, etc. I think most homeowners do, unless they are just slum landlords. I would be livid to find out that a tenant was airbnbing a room or the house out without permission. And would have no qualms about immediately evicting the tenant and their airbnb guest.