Hi @Brian686,
I so sympathize with your issue on this. Hosts should not be penalized in anyway because a guest can’t be bothered to clean up after themselves. But the fact remains that we are. I had some guests that stayed for a week while they were doing some research in the local sand dunes and regularly brought sand back with them. In their private review they said the whole house needed vacuuming. Well of course it did, they tracked sand all over it. (First Time AirBnB users as well) they were not the only ones that graded me down on cleanliness when it was their own doing, but they were the first so they stand out. Fortunately it has only happened a couple of times. If it had happened much more than that I might’ve thought there was some validity to it.
The other thing that gets on my nerves is when they knock you down on the cleanliness rating for things that have nothing to do with whether the house is clean or not. And example of this would be somebody saw a couple of ants in the bathroom. We are in rainforest country. Everybody in our area has issues with ants at one time or another coming in the house generally looking for water during the dry season. All the guest had to do was let me know and we would’ve taken care of it. It wasn’t even a whole trail of ants it was just a couple of random ants. <sigh>
There is nothing we can do about it after the fact. It’s frustrating, it’s annoying, and at times it’s even maddening. My listing clearly states there is no ongoing housekeeping while they are in residence. But yet somehow it is our fault when they don’t clean up after themselves. I do have cleaning equipment available if they need it. It just simply isn’t our fault if they do not choose to use it. I wish I knew a way to prevent this low grade when it’s in their doing, but I have no idea how to stop it.