@Jasmine343
I agree with pretty much everything that's been said above.
Making sure that the place is sufficiently equipped for the maximum number of guests you accommodate and the listing is accurate about amenities are very important.
Catering to a guest's every whim by providing items and services not listed (especially ones that other guests do not request) is a slippery slope. These demanding types will keep on demanding and are unlikely to leave a great review even if you do bend over backwards for them.
My worst review was from a couple who
Pre-arrival
- Wanted to know what food was included because they couldn't find it on the listing. The tea, coffee, sugar, oil etc etc that I supply is all listed, but they expected me to buy their food and cook for them!
Pre-arrival and during stay - I am always happy to help guests with questions, tips and advice, but this was like they expected a concierge service, e.g. sourcing specialist magazines, car rental arrangements for an unrelated trip, taking packages prior to arrival, going to the pharmacy at night to buy specific things, on and on...
During stay
- Wanted a stove top coffee maker, because that's what they use at home. I have three different types of coffee machines/makers but, no, they wanted the same type as at home. Apparently a French press is 'dangerous' and they didn't even try to use the two coffee machines.
- Used an insane amount of coffee and sugar and didn't thank me when I went to the shop at 10pm to buy them more white sugar because they wouldn't use the brown.
- Said the lights switches for the communal hallways should be located in their bedroom, not in the hallways, and therefore all lights must remain on overnight (energy efficiency is mentioned in my listing).
- Said it was 'ridiculous' that I didn't have a waste disposal in the sink, even though no one in the UK has these.
At the same time, these guests broke numerous house rules and helped themselves to my personal items (which are put away in cupboards that are not shared with guests) and were extremely rude.
After that experience, I thought, never again. I am happy to provide additional items if asked nicely and it's not going to be much extra/expense or effort, and actually do quite frequently, but guests who make these unreasonable kind of demands will simply be reminded that the amenities are as listed. If they still don't get it and are rude about it to boot, they will be told politely to find somewhere else.