retaliatory reviews

Answered!
Craig791
Level 3
Hamilton, New Zealand

retaliatory reviews

Hi guys, 

I started to host on AirBNB a few months ago. So far, there's been a few hiccups along the way but i've always been one to aim to please. One guest I had booked the home sighting that he had a family wedding, so him and his family would be staying - i accepted the reservation even though he had no review history. 

He came, checked in, all was going fine untill I get a call from my neighbour at 9pm saying that there's a party happening. Now in addition to the no parties tick on my advert, I also highlight in my house rules that this is a no parties property. I text the guest, who didnt reply. I then logged onto my cameras (which is noted on the advert), to see 35 people outside on the deck.  I then contact Airbnb to lodge an issue and drove to the property. When I was there, the house was a complete mess with drinks spilt all through the lounge, cofetti everywhere, big 21st baloons and alot of food/alcohol/music and people. I asked to speak to the guest (not knowing which one he was), who finally came over and asked me how much money i'd like to leave them be. I explained that I do not want any money and that he had breached my rules. I asked him to leave the property.  I had to get commercial cleaners in to sort the property out and remove stains the following day. 

However, obviously I gave this guest a not to shining review. In return, he gave me a scathing 1 star review, rating the home, location, cleanliness etc all poorly. 

An investigation was launched into Airbnb, and i was fine with the conclusion. However, Airbnb have declined to remove his review, even though i explained it was reteliation and that every other guest had given it 5 stars. 

I sent them detailed screenshots of the party occuring, all the people, and consequently the mess that was left behind. To no avail, they just won't remove it. 

Any ideas what I can do?

Top Answer
Craig791
Level 3
Hamilton, New Zealand

Thank you Jenny. I was sent a message and explained the situation and it’s now been removed! Phew 

View Top Answer in original post

20 Replies 20

Aslea 

 

It's being ignored in the US as well. My situation occurred Jun 2023 when a guest violated the policy that was made clear.  Our policy clearly states no parties, functions or events and we have CCTv Camera. Armed with this information Airbnb cancelled the reservation. But the guest was able to leave a retaliatory review and it's obvious all categories were 1. Said we had roaches, ants, the place wasn't as describe. Airbnb will not remove the review even though we had 4 guest prior to this one who praise the accommodation and 1 after. Out 42 reviews on 2 have been retaliatory. I now have a listing issue from Airbnb saying we may be suspended or removed if additional issues are reported.  I agree it's not right.  I can only hope other guest can see through this since Airbnb can not. 

Mike-And-Jane0
Top Contributor
England, United Kingdom

@Craig791 really good to see the new policy does work (at least eventually)

Hello @Craig791 

I had a similar situation where a had video cameras to support my case. Airbnb cancelled the reservation but left the 1 star review. You can tell it's retaliatory but I can't get them to remove it.   I've since had only one guest to stay after that whose review states that our place was as expected no issues. What did you do to get the review removed.

Sorry to hear this. One of the community managers got a person to contact me. I guess it depends which Airbnb support worker you get on the day. Definitely frustrating when there’s a clear breach of policy! 

So Airbnb policy is you must post on this forum to get a retaliatory review removed?

Stephen

So in order to remove a review, a request from a Community Manager must be received by Airbnb?

Stephen