@Lina4227 It's notoriously hard to win a resolutions claim on an issue that seems to be in the grey area between physical damage and a home-maintenance concern. Hopefully you don't have to initiate another request for compensation anytime soon, but if you must, make sure your case is airtight.
I don't know of a surefire way to prevent breakage or critical reviews, but you can definitely change how you publicly respond to them. One of the most common mistakes hosts make is to forget that the audience for this public response is their prospective guests - everything you write there becomes a part of your advertisement.