Addressing an Unwarranted Review

Janine560
Level 1
New York, NY

Addressing an Unwarranted Review

Dear Airbnb Community,

 

As a dedicated Superhost, I’ve always taken pride in providing exceptional experiences for my guests. Recently, however, I encountered a review that  was unwarranted and does not accurately reflect the quality of my hosting.

 

The guest in question left a low rating despite clear evidence and prior communications that contradicted their claims. I have documented text messages that support my case, and yet Airbnb has determined that the review does not meet their criteria for removal.

 

I’m sharing my experience here to highlight the challenges that hosts can face and to seek support and advice from fellow hosts. I remain committed to providing top-notch hospitality and appreciate the community’s understanding and any guidance you can offer.

 

Thank you for your time and support.

 

Janine

1 Reply 1
ManiKu0
Level 3
Zirakpur, India

My lovely friend Janine, I can truly feel your emotions. I recently went through a similar experience, but we must stay consistent — after all, we’re dealing with humans. It’s not easy to please real, grown adults. I often remind myself that even making a child happy can be difficult, so trying to make adults happy is certainly a complex task.

 

These guests come from different continents, beliefs, expectations, and completely unimaginable mindsets.

 

Let me share a quick story: one guest called me at 1 AM saying, “I just checked in — where’s the switch to turn on the lights?” I replied, “My lovely guest, it’s right next to the door.” He said, “It worked, thanks.” Imagine his situation — he had just finished a long drive, was exhausted, and simply wasn’t thinking clearly. He still gave me a good rating.

 

Another guest arrived around the same time and asked the same question. I said, “Just look on the wall — it’s a big switchboard, clearly visible.” He didn’t respond but left a low rating the next day.

I’ve learned that when a guest arrives at midnight, it’s best to speak softly and kindly. These small gestures come with hosting experience and a deeper understanding of people.

More tools to help you meet your goals

Resource Center

Explore guides for hospitality, managing your listing, and growing your business.