@Bryce-and-Steve0 trying to figure out how to improve a listing's search ranking has got to be one of the most asked questions by hosts. (Possibly only behind "I canceled a booking; why is my calendar is blocked?")
Just search this Discussion Board for "Ranking" or "Listing Ranking" or "Search Ranking" or "Listing Visibility" and you will find a lot of lively discussion about how the rankings of listings is done.
I looked for your listing, and when the map had 158 listings on it, yours was #95 (page 6).
No one outside AirBnB's search algorithm group can answer definitely, but I am happy to share what information I have been able to gather.
AirBnB is deliberately vague on how ranking is done. Here is their information page about it:
https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/39/what-factors-determine-how-my-listing-appears-in-search-resul...
Here is one AirbnB blog entry about search matching:
https://blog.atairbnb.com/how-search-makes-the-best-matches/
Here is a very informative AirBnB blog entry about how to rank higher (I think this one is the best):
https://blog.atairbnb.com/search/
Finally, here is a Reddit post where someone did a small bit of analysis about search ranking:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AirBnB/comments/6113kx/ranking_of_listing_factors_correlating_to_search/?st...
If you don't have time to read all the links, here are some highlights (in no particular order):
- Instant Book: Very Helpful
- SuperHost status: Not supposed to be a factor.
- Being the kind of host that *is* a SuperHost: Definitely a factor.
- Tweaking your listing every day: Not Helpful
- Being put on lots of people's Wish Lists: Very Good
- Getting clicked on (views): Good
- Receiving inquiries: Good
- Competitive price: Very Good.
- Declining people’s booking requests: Bad
- Positive Ratings from Guests: Good
- Having lots of reviews: Good
- Being a new listing: Very Good
- Being responsive to guests: Good
- Cancelling a confirmed booking: Very Bad
Also: be aware that the way the search results are ranked can vary from one guest to another. Just because you are high or low in the list for one guest doesn’t mean you will be in that position for ALL guests.