Hi Allison,
I completely understand what you were dealing with as a host.
Although I did not have your exact situation, it mimics some of the issues that I have had with guest reviews.
I believe the negative reviews should not be left unless there is a evaluation of the situation, especially if Having good reviews.
My concern is that guest get to leave A negative review without having contacted the host first to explain what’s going on. That would at least give you the host and opportunity to rectify the situation and make the guest stay even more pleasant.
Or even offering a refund when necessary.
I also think your case that Airbnb should take that down and it not be counted against you.
Especially when it’s a circumstance that is out of your control.
I am concerned that guest get to leave reviews, negative reviews, when it is a situation that is out of your control.
The solution:
We should be allowed to negative reviews once a year.
Especially if you have pretty good reviews going along, you should be allowed at least one grade to be dropped from the overall average like they used to do in school.
I hope that makes sense
I look forward to Airbnb reviewing these policies and reevaluating how they can make things better for everyone.