Ok so I am hosting from 2 months and my guests were so happy...
Latest reply
Ok so I am hosting from 2 months and my guests were so happy, everyone leave 5-star. Until it happens. A guest booked for her...
Latest reply
Hello Airbnb community!
We had a guest cancel within 24 hours of staying with us due to having sick children (which is completely understandable) and we even use the "Flexible" cancellation policy. However, she was still able to leave us a review for which she had no basis.
Prior to her review, we had received over 50 FIVE star reviews. Her FOUR star review was the first one. I know it is really a small drop in the bucket but it is still upsetting when we spend so much time and energy to give guests a five star experience. I
have submitted a request to Airbnb to NOT allow guests to leave a review if they cancel or to prompt them to answer different questions (i.e. Was the host understanding when you needed to cancel? Did they attempt to help you in another way by providing different dates or referring you to another Airbnb in the area?, etc.). I really hope this policy changes because a guest who cancels should not be able to review us on questions for which he/she has no basis.
Has anyone else provided similiar feedback to Airbnb?
Answered! Go to Top Answer
As I remember from the summer, some consumer groups had major concerns about guests who were unable to leave a review about a place they found on, or before, or just after arrival that was unsuitable, misrepresented or issues with the host and so on.
I think the British Competition and Markets Authority was at least one of the bodies asking airbnb to change the ability to leave a review as previously it was nigh on impossible to record a review and alert other prospective guests of a full picture of a bad listing. Airbnb changed this from September to allow reviews to be recorded and left for cancellations within 24 hours of the commencement of a booking.
In your case, the guests are allowed to leave a review because of the timeframe involved, but of course it doesn't really meet the spirit of why leaving a review was necessary. It also explains why airbnb are reluctant to remove the review as well, however they should probably really consider it in your case.
In consolation because 'star' marks are very much arbitarily awarded and beyond your control, you should decide for yourself whether you should really give them so much prominence and weight. I am of the belief your future clients will look at your listing description, pore over your photographs and read reviews - and be supremly indifferent to whether you are 5.0 or 4.99 starred or indeed a superhost.
No you do not need to let the star rating go. . .People book or choose not to book depending on star ratings and reviews. I once declined to book a place based on one terrible review. We need HONEST reviews on Airbnb to make gusting/hostig decisions. How is it that someone who cancels on the same day and never steps foot in your home can give you a full review that effects your star rating and Superhost status? What if the person gives a spiteful review and gives you all one-star ratings on things they could not possibly judge: Cleanliness, accuracy, whether they recommend you to others. This is outrageous!!
@Leigh-Anne-and-Jonathan0 I also read the review (from Michelle, right ?) and it’s a good review. I understand that that’s not the issue. The question is why does AIRBNB allow people who did not even stay at a listing to give it a review. This is not the first time I’ve heard of this and I’m wondering what’s going on. But I will advise is that the second you get a review that you’re not happy with, a jump on the phone with AIRBNB to try to
rectify it. I have been told that we have within 48 hours to try to get things to change. The big thing is DON’T leave a response to a guest review. Once you do that, Airbnb says They can’t change anything. Of course, it’s their site and We know they can change anything if they want to. They have just chosen not to set it up that way.
@Kat17, no that’s not true, I had two reviews removed since 2010. Both had been answered as the process takes time and you don’t know, if they will do it. The first, many years ago, at a time, when reviews were published as they came in. Horror guest, I left a bad review of them, they copied mine and pasted it back. Claimedan error... at that time, airbnb removed only the review, but left the answer, which looked strange and made no sense.
This year, I got a racist review. It took 6 weeks to get it removed, with the answer, but not mine of them. That was a bit annoying, as I had left a neutral one. Then, a few more weeks later, when I looked up his profile again, my review was gone and another furious exchange too, were he abused another host, even in the public answer on his own profile. This exchange were “only” insults, but the motivation was the same. I did not know the other host, but had drawn airbnb’s attention to it. That took longer, but in the end, the answers don’t cement it in. And they no longer overhang lonely on your profile.
I've been on the phone with a case manager for days now, but that is NOT what I was told. Case manager said they will NOT remove a review unless it "violates their Review Guidelines." They agreed with me--that the guest who chose to cancel with 15 minutes of arrival should NOT have left a long, negative review, but she could NOT remove it because it fell within their Guidelines.
You MUST submit complaints to Airbnb at : https://www.airbnb.com/help/feedback Airbnb does NOT make changes based on these Community discussions.
C & K,
Tried the link and here's what I got:
Oops! We can't seem to find the page you're looking for.
I wonder if the feedback link has changed or maybe they don't allow this kind of feedback anymore?
Thanks, and I'm being asked now to review a Cancelled Guest. Weird. Have sent AirBnB a message about it already waiting their reply.
Thanks for all your help everyone.
@Mark396......Mark, here is the correct Feedback link.....
https://www.airbnb.ca/help/feedback
@Leigh-Anne-and-Jonathan0 @Cynthia43 @Kat
As a note to others on this thread the automated Airbnb review system will allow a review to be posted if the cancellation takes place on the day of the scheduled arrival. In this case both host and guest will be offered the opportunity to write and post a review.
But, Airbnb will not allow a review for a stay that did not eventuate, so as long as the guest did not arrive at the property Airbnb will remove any review that reflects that a stay did take place.
This is standard procedure and is far more common than many realise.
Cheers.....Rob
I was told that if someone who never stepped foot in the lisiting gives a review/star rating on cleanliness, or some other thing that they could not possibly know about - Airbnb WILL remove the review. Please also see my last posts on the main thread. Airbnb SAYS they are aware of the issue and they are 'talking about getting it resolved'????
I find Airbnb customer service to be severly lacking -- even the "Phone Number Reserved for Superhosts!" It's the same connection (literally and figuratively) as the regular phone number. . .
@Leigh-Anne-and-Jonathan0 "a guest who cancels should not be able to review us "
I agree, it's absurd if they never set foot on the property. A "FAKE" review certainly seems contrary to Airbnb stated goals " to promote transparency and trust".
Please submit that complaint to Airbnb at; https://www.airbnb.com/help/feedback They don't read these boards.
Interesting that this is still their position on the internet:
"All the reviews on Airbnb are written by hosts and travellers from our community, so any review you see is based on a stay that a guest had in a host's listing."
https://www.airbnb.com.au/help/article/13/how-do-reviews-work
Seems the "stay that a guest had in a host's listing" part is no longer valid and they shoud remove it from their help articles at least...
Lisa
This exact senario just happened to me. I recently had a guest cancel the day of her reservation. After the canceled reservation dates had ended, I got an email to review the guest. I called the Airbnb support line to see if this was an error as she did not stay at the home since the reservation was cancelled. However, I was notified that this is the NEW Airbnb policy. It was not like this in the past. I have been a host for over a year and this new policy was only put into place 2 months ago. As a host, I don't feel I should review this guest. Regardless of how the communication was prior to the cancelled stay, she did not stay at my home. I cannot say anything about how she was as a guest, if she respected the home, house rules, or left it clean or dirty at check out. This is what I use to write guests reviews. On the other end, she did not stay in my house. So why would she get the opportunity to make a review of my listing when she did not stay in the house, use the amenities, or enjoy all the little details I put into my home to make each guests stay comfortable and memorable. I work very hard to get high reviews and maintain my super host status. Although I have only had a few last minute cancellations, I am not happy about this new policy. It seems highly unfair to allow someone to make any form of review on a service, in this case is lodging, when they did not access the listing or use the service. It really appears to negate the entire review process. I hope that Airbnb reconsiders this policy. I have written to Airbnb, using the feedback option, to state the above opinion. Perhaps if enough of us hosts write in to them, they will reconsider.
nevermind.
"I have written to Airbnb, using the feedback option, to state the above opinion. Perhaps if enough of us hosts write in to them, they will reconsider.' I did too. Please - EVERYBODY write in! https://www.airbnb.com/help/feedback It is completely unbelievable that people can review a listing if they have never stepped foot inside it.
Yes. I totally agree with you. I just got a cancellation a few hours before his coming. Not sure about his reviews. He only mentioned it’s emergency.