Hi @Karl1552,
Are you a new host to airbnb?
I ask this because it's less about the insurance company you choose (they all will be rubbish when it comes to claiming unless you take the most expensive one you can find) and more about how you plan to manage, maintain your airbnbs?
We've had several insurance companies cover our airbnb, and honestly that's not been the issue. As long as you choose something that does cover short term let, it doesn't matter who.
It's what's in the airbnb that also causes issues, not who is insurance company. eg Spa's, firepits or things that have a higher safety risk, so consider all those if you are first time airbnb host.
You get a reasonable cover via airbnb claims for guest breakage etc. Never had to claim on insurance for guest issues.
What we have had to claim on is when you get some weather related damage or similar that impacts your rental or guest income. Like a leaking roof from a storm.
We had that, called them up, sent out some emergency repair person, made it worse and for another 6 months had leaking issues. Honestly, we would have been better off not claiming, and if we were more handy, just fix the **bleep** things ourselves. We ended up getting our own builder to fix and still fighting the insurance company for the lost rental income for 1 less room and partial refunds we had to get, apart from labour and materials.
So in summary, don't dwell on it too much, invest in really good trades that you can have on speed dial if you can't fix things yourself. Use them instead of using the insurance company. And do a serious safety risk assessment of your properties.
Trying to claim for loss of short term holiday let rental income is really tricky so try to prevent that in the first place. Keep the insurance for big problems like it burning down or the like, or guest sues you because they did something completely stupid...
My 2 cents worth from NSW
Good luck, MK