Reporting bad reviews

Kate147
Level 2
Cape Town, South Africa

Reporting bad reviews

I have been hosting since October 2016 and had really lovely experiences with guests up until April this year where I had a family come in and pretty much trash our place. They left such a mess that steam cleaning had to be called in as well as extra services to fix broken items. I had a second experience like that in May this year - same issue of broken items, trashed the place etc. 

 

In both cases I had requested money from the guest - one of the services that Air BnB offers which invovles the security deposit that is held for 2 weeks after the guest has departed.

 

My problem is that I requested money from both guests BEFORE they left me a review. So, they already knew I was shocked and disappointed by the state they left my apartment in, so therefore their reviews were bias and prejudice. They both rated my less than 5 *, which can affect my SuperHost status. I have replied to both reviews with my side of the story, but surely these reviews of theirs can count as comepletely prejudice and this is not in line with Air BnBs standards?

 

If anyone can help with a suggestion on how to get a review removed due to it being bias and prejudice, please let me know! U have "reported" both reviews a nunmber of times without any luck or response from Air BnB.

 

Thanks!

3 Replies 3
Oomesh-Kumarsingh0
Level 10
Pamplemousses, Mauritius

@Kate147 Did you make some photos of the damages and mess that those guests made to your property? If you have proof contact Airbnb on the following number South Africa: +1-855-424-7262 (toll-free) and let them know the situation with such terrible guests also send Airbnb some photos as proof if you have any. Fingers cross they will remove those bad reviews. Good luck!!!

Hi Oomesh, thank you for your response! 

 

I did indeed take many pics, which I submitted in my request for money. It is the fact that I cannot get his review removed that is stressing me out and which I find totally unfair. But I will try call them to speak about it directly, as reporting the review is certainly not working for me. 😞

Robin4
Top Contributor
Mount Barker, Australia

@Kate147

Kate maybe you can learn to look a little bit closer at the way booking requests are coming to you. I notice you are not using 'Instant Book' so a prospective guest cannot just book without contacting you.

What I do is study the wording of the request, and this will give me a big insight into what this person may be like to host.

If someone comes to me with......."We have seen your lovely cottage and would like to stay for a couple of days to get away from the kids for a while"......I can't hit that accept button fast enough! I don't want to see their past history, they have come to me in a complimentary, passive way and I know they will be good respectful guests!

If someone says........"We are coming to Mt Barker and want to book for ******* is there offstreet parking? What cooking is available? What is the latest we can checkout?"........This is an aggresive approach, and aggressive people do not tend to be good guests! I want to do a lot more digging around, I want to see some good past reviews, and if I do not feel comfortable I would decline the request.

 

The other thing Kate you are in a pretty picky part of the price bracket. You have a base rate of $216au per night for the first guest and an additional guest is charged at a rate of $161ua pr night. Kate, it is a beautiful apartment but these are pretty big figures....a couple is going to have to pay an absolute minimum of $465au including cleaning fee and the ABB service fee to stay a night in your apartment, $576au for 3 people. Wow, that is getting up there and guests who pay that much are going to feel pretty much entitled to do whatever they want. You are going to attract 'wanabees' who's thought for others is going to be extremely limited. It may pay to look at that pricing structure a bit and try to work your way into a less entitled part of the market. You also have a wonderful lot of 'atmosphere' there but all these things are things that can be broken and it may pay to streamline the apartment just a bit so there is less temptation there!

As far as getting a review removed, that can be a bit difficult if the guests review was based around their perceptions, and from reading both of them that would appear to be the case. These reviews are not slanderous of defamatory, they are just the guests thoughts about the treatment they received from their point of view....they aren't dishonest, just the way they felt. Never say never, it may be worth getting onto ABB but I would not think either of these reviews warrant removal. 

I hope some of this can be of help to you Kate.

Cheers.....Rob