Hi Linsey, I would separate the pricing-tool question from the commercial math.
Before deciding whether Airbnb pricing or PriceLabs is better, I’d test a few sample dates: weekdays, weekends, peak dates and slower dates. For each one, compare:
1. the guest-facing total price
2. your expected host payout after Airbnb fees
3. any tax/VAT impact if relevant
4. comparable listings nearby
5. your minimum acceptable net nightly income
A pricing tool can suggest demand, but I’d still keep manual guardrails for peak nights, minimum payout and shoulder periods. If the fee structure has changed, a simple percentage increase may not fully protect your net result.
For me the key question would be: which setup gives the right occupancy without giving away nights that would probably have booked anyway?