I have a similar problem:
I have a new listing as of Jan 1, 2020. At first I had no filters for who could book and my first guest had no profile pic, no GOV ID uploaded and no reviews or recommendations. That guest had a party and it was a huge issue, I obviously do not want that to happen again so I changed my filters so that guests profiles must have a profile picture, uploaded GOV ID and have positive reviews and recommendations. My listing is also set to Instant Book.
I keep getting lots of requests from profiles who do not meet my standards and I am having to decline them which has now affected my Acceptance Reservations % to be at 71% which is not good. I want to become a super host so how do I deal with this issue? Why are profiles that dont meet my criteria able to request to book?