@Megan-and-Chase0, you are correct in that it will be hard at this late date to figure out what other AirBnB listings were priced at: all those listings are already booked and won't show up!
In these circumstances I have turned to Beyond Pricing and Wheelhouse, which let you put in your actual listing, to get their guesses of what the price should be.
Since your listing is this: https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/22077157
This is your listing on the Wheelhouse demo:
https://www.usewheelhouse.com/demo?listingId=18441468&source=A
(you need to dismiss the dialog by clicking on the "Continue to sample calendar").
It shows the pricing it would set, which tops out at $2,084 - $2,104 / night on Superbowl weekend..
This is your listing on the Beyond Pricing demo:
https://beyondpricing.com/preview/22077157
Beyond pricing has it priced at $2,138 - $2,418 / night on Superbowl weekend. (And for some reason, nearly doubles the price the week after the game).
Best of luck with your listing!