Yes, it’s a big flaw. I’ve decided not make claims for minor damages, but instead give the guests the bad review they deserve. (Assuming the damages were theft, vandalism or negligence and there was no attempt to make things right.)
I’m still fairly new, so a retaliatory 1* review from a guest who was upset about the damage claim would be a bigger problem for me than missing towels or crayon marks on my walls.
One exception would, be if the guest wrote a review right after checking out. Then putting in a claim would be less risky, since it would happen after the guest review was already locked in.
As I get more reviews I’ll be in a better position to absorb low star ratings. Then I’ll become more active with claiming.