I have encountered some very nice reviewed guests who had never done dl until they booked my place. Here are some factors I have considered with my keeping this requirement:
-I live in a HOA that is not totally on board with the idea of Airbnb, so as a nod to them I keep it on.
-I live in the home I rent.
-I only charge about $40 a night, and probably wouldn't be able to raise my rates. This isn't the Hamptons, it's a suburb of the largest city in Idaho. Most people are just passing through for a night.
-I'm pretty new as a host.
I could imagine scenarios where I wouldn't care as much about the govt ID verification. But, for now I am keeping it.