Announcements

Winter Release Q&A with Airbnb’s Christy Schrader

Winter Release Q&A session

Reviews

Answered!
Irma370
Level 2
PG, Montenegro

Reviews

Hello, do you   owners have  same problems as we do,like  guests  are  very nice and they  come to spend  their  time  with us, when they are  in our place everything  is top 10, no complains ,no  regrets, many words of  gratefulness ,but  tomorrow there  is like  akward, very bad reviews and  low scores, which are  not  exact  or objective any way? It has become very periplexing , and  annoying .Thank you  in advance 🫶

Top Answer
Robin4
Top Contributor
Mount Barker, Australia

@Irma370 

Irma, the Airbnb review system is problematic for hosts, it is not like a normal review system where you have a floating average rating, with both plus and minus increments either side......'Average 3.9 * from 247 reviews'!

Airbnb's review system is more of a punishment system than a reward system, there is only 1 default rating which every host is told they should strive to achieve and that is 5 star. Anything less than 5 star means the host has some work to do to be that Airbnb default host.

 

Obviously Irma, this is nonsensical! Every guest has a differing idea of perfection.....to some there is no such thing as 5 star! It is that perfection that doesn't exist. Most guests just don't understand the way it works and they give reviews like this......

crazy star ratings.png

The host can learn absolutely nothing from a review like that, but still gets penalised for it!

 

And because of the way the review system is structured it is almost useless as a guide to guest or host relevance because, we all pat each other on the back and say what great people we are regardless of the actual experience to avoid getting a poor review.

We see many complaints from hosts about a guest who had 8 five star previous reviews, but turned out to be a disaster of a guest and knew how to manipulate the review system.

 

In your situation Irma, even your rating doesn't add up, even using Airbnb's maths!!! Your 2 Bed listing has 8 reviews of which 6 have been 5 star, one a 4 and one a 3.

Out of a possible 40 stars you have 37. Thirty seven as a percentage of forty is......... 92. Your overall rating on that listing should be 4.9!   But it is 4.6!

 

You have a listing which most of your guests love and have given you great reviews so, you are not doing anything wrong, and you won't influence Airbnb to change the review system so, you have to work with it.

This is my method of educating guests as to how it operates. This page is prominent in my House Rules folder, and most guests are shocked when they read it and realise that, by trying to be constructive and help the host, they were actually hurting them......

airbnb ratings 2.png

 

Don't get too disheartened Irma, we all have to deal with it, just concentrate on being the best host you can be, and let those great written reviews you have do the talking and don't worry about the star ratings.

 

Cheers........Rob.

View Top Answer in original post

18 Replies 18

Just got to say, love this note! I will be stealing some parts of this, if thats ok?

I find with a 6 bedroom farm property I'm constantly having to explain/justify that a spiderweb or two doesn't mean the property isn't clean, and therefore i shouldn't get a rating of 4 just because of that....the larger the property the harder to manage guest expectations on reviews!

Thank  you @Mary1523 ,so much .❤️

Farah148
Level 5
San Jose, CA

@Irma370 Totally agree with you.  I don’t understand how people, even if host is the first to reach out and offer any help if needed, can stay silent and not give the host an opportunity to at least try and rectify any issues they have.  I had a guest, that I knew might be a little more high maintenance—using AirReview extension, I saw that they rated some hosts 4 stars even though they noted they would book again and their detailed review had no noted faults.  So, I wasn’t surprised that they gave me an overall 5 star, but gave a 3 star for check-in because they had a hard time seeing numbers on the smart lock (it’s one of those with numbers that light up once you press the screen, and was noted on my instructions before check-in).  I sent a welcome message, letting them know to reach out with any issues…if they had said something about the lock, I would have provided a manual key for them to use.  I’m also perplexed that they also mentioned an issue about something else that wasn’t actually an issue on my part, and they acknowledged issue was on them. Thankfully, the only impact on the 3 star check-in rating is that my listing is considered top 10%, instead of 5% now.

@Farah148 , I do not  know what happened with a people , but this  year ,I  have a feelling  to working in a Manging  Terorism Center,  but Tourism , considering guests  reviews, and all of the complaining .😕😊🫶