I had a guest instant book for a checkin today. We have a st...
Latest reply
I had a guest instant book for a checkin today. We have a strict 4pm checkin time & they showed up at 2:15 saying they chose ...
Latest reply
Perhaps I am looking for a place to vent and sorry for making this so long, but I have a guest in my home for 3 days. I should specify this is not my home this is a secondary home that I chose to Airbnb because of the flexibility Airbnb allows. What I am wondering is when it comes time to review should I click recommend or not recommend, by clicking not recommend this impacts the guest by them not being able to instantly book but by doing this it allows future hosts to review previous comments before accepting. Therefore I guess the question is would the hosting community want the option to review this guest before accepting them?
I received the following communication late at night from my current guest,
“Good evening, we have things to tell you about the house: the chairs break the wood does not hold it is very very dangerous ... there is no stove nor enough glass of wine for 5 people there has no salad bowls nor peel vegetable and little dishes for a complete family! Given the price of accommodation we are disappointed!”
This message and the messages there after seem to have rubbed me the wrong way, and I wonder upon check out should I be giving them a poor review and not recommend them to other hosts, would other hosts not want to host this guest or am I over reacting. I am not sure if it is the accusatory tone in the message or the over use of exclamation marks but I am sure this will result in a negative review from the guest.
A little more to the story, this guest is a fell host and is from France, I have hosted other hosts in the past and I would expect the communication would be more fluid and less accusatory more helpful as in hey we would really like some wine glasses can you bring some over.
If a guest leaves my home and private messages me that I should add this or that to the home, I generally will pick it up and have it there for the next guest, if they message me during their stay and I feel it is reasonable I will get what they need and drop it of asap.
In this scenario the chairs, yes one of the chairs broke I am assuming that the chairs have been misused by past guests and wear and tear has occurred, they obviously will need to be replaced soon. In relation to there being no stove, they meant there was no pans for a family of 5 when I went over they only found 1 small fry pan 2 large pots, 1 small pot, previous guests put the other two large fry pans and the baking sheets in the drawer of the stove and the guests did not look. The vegetable peeler, they are right I don’t have one, personally I don’t use them I use a knife to peel vegetables, and there are three knives at the home. The house has 6 salad plates, 6 cereal bowls, 6 dinner plates (just found out only 5 as someone has broken one), 6 spoons, forks, butter knives, 6 coffee mugs, 4 espresso cups and saucers, 6 glasses, 4 plastic cups, 2 wine glasses (left by previous guests) am I expected to have every comfort of home including wine glasses, potato peelers, lemon zesters etc. I have bowls I guess they were looking for a large mixing bowl to put a family size salad in. I feel my price is reasonable, they are paying $152 Canadian dollars for a fully furnished 3 bdrm home with a kitchen a bathroom and newly renovated, considering hotels in the area without a kitchen would cost about $250-300 for 4 people I considered the $152 to be more than reasonable but obviously as they stated they are very disappointed. Is this a guest that other hosts would want to be warned about?
Translate:
The lodgings are not as described and not what you would normally consider an entire place listing. It is a second listing in the basement. Very far from Toronto, you would need minimum 45 minutes driving time to get to the city center, often one hour as the road is at times congested. Basic kitchen utensils missing and the sofabed had stains, the chairs were in bad condition (they came apart, the screws were loose). However, the host was there and replaced them.
Above all there is a serious noise issue as the place is very close to the highway (in private feedback it also says "no soundproofing" points in a negative direction)
Not very good value for money.
Thank you for taking the time to translate, this is similar to what a co worker had translated for me but more descriptive, thank you again. So based on this sounds like my listing should be taken down as it is incorrect, again, thank you for your help.
I personally don't think that the expectations are unrealistic. If I rent a place with a kitchen, I expect to find the basics there. And honestly, more than one dish per person is in fact bare minimum. If I had a home that slept 4, I'd personally have twelve of everything.
As for her comments about noise, location, and value - those are her judgements. What bothers her, may not bother you. But it's still her opinion and so the review is valid.
Do you feel the fact that I did not have a potato peeler and wine glasses should result in a 2/5 rating and being reported to airbnb for an inaccurate listing for wifi, accuracy, noise and listing description.
Her review - both public and private is about MUCH more than a potato peeler and wine glasses. You keep mentioning them, but those were examples of what she sees as a much bigger problem.
The listing doesn't mention another apartment in the basement. So she sees that as inaccurate.
She feels the time to Toronto is more than mentioned, so again she sees it as inaccurate.
She feels that the highway noise is more than makes her happy for the price of the apartment. Acceptable noise levels are relative. I personally have very low noise tolerances, and yet, I don't even notice when military jets roar over my house... because it's my normal.
A broken chair is an issue.
Wifi isn't mentioned in eithe review so I have no idea where that comes from.
I'm betting if only one item on the list above were an issue for her, the review would be very different. If a chair breaks and it's an isolated incident... most people will laugh it off.
If you make a wonderful dinner, but have to drink your wine from a juice cup (so long as it's glass, lol) most people won't notice the lack of wine glasses.
But if after a longer than expected drive in traffic, you struggle with making dinner for lack of basic tools, have to drink your wine from a plastic cup or coffee cup (didn't see anything glass in the listing photos), wifi is slower than one hopes, the traffic is roaring past, and then a chair breaks... yeah, I can see leaving a less than glowing review. Her expectation and her reality were not matched.
Your listing still shows 4.5* and her review, whilst not glowing wouldn't put anyone off. I'd let this go and move on.