@Kim4581
I couldn't really tell from youur reviews what is the Guest reason for considering your property? Like my rentals are usually I guess middle term work related rentals,some it is because it is close to an attraction or beach. Just guessing but you have multiple 1 or a few nights which I am guessing people stopping on their way to an intended destination.
You have good reviews so accepting wasn't a bbad thing butt a very hard market to build on.
Do some investigation off other STR s in your area. What are they focusing on, you may be surprised at what your niche market should be?