I am now already in a +10 day discussion with Airbnb on an i...
Latest reply
I am now already in a +10 day discussion with Airbnb on an issue of blocked days that are being switched to 'active' in the c...
Latest reply
Is it fair for someone to give a ratings of one (1) for value for money when they were refunded for a particular day or two?
Answered! Go to Top Answer
@Ricardo741 Ah, I see. Typical entitled guest leaving a revenge review. Sorry you had that, especially on your first review. In that case, I would contact Airbnb again, and ask them to remove the review, based on him mentioning the refund in his review. It's against Airbnb review policy for a host or guest to speak to an Airbnb resolution process or outcome in their review. If you get an unhelpful or unknowledgable CS rep, just thank them for their time and call back, hopefully you'll get someone better. You might have to do this several times. look up the review rules first in Airbnb's Terms of Service, so you can quote the appropriate policy to them.
If they still won't remove the review, you can respond to it. Make your response brief, factual and professional, not all you wrote here, just that the guest was insistent on coming, even though you told him that your rules require more notice, but you accommodated his request under the understanding that the unit was not yet ready and cleaned. That many demands were made that you considered to be unreasonable but that you did your best to comply with, that he made it difficult for your staff to do their job, as he kept disappearing with the keys, etc. Condense the situation into a short paragraph and don't mention the refund.
@Ricardo741 Without knowing the circumstances of the refund, it's hard to comment. Did he stay for some period of time and was refunded one day for some reason? Did he not stay at all and get refunded his payment?
A 1* for value seems totally unfair to any host, unless the listing is priced high for the area and the competition and is dirty, or doesn't contain the amenities promised, or necessary items are broken or non-functional.
If the guest didn't stay at all and was refunded, you should contact Airbnb to ask for the review to be removed.
This gentleman was deceptive in my opionion but i could not judge him on that basis because I do not have records as evidence. Our policy is that each guest must give at least three (3) days notice before the commencement of their booking. This man only gave me two (2) hours, and with a lenthy explanation that won my sympathy. He stated that he had booked somewhere that became unavailable and was basically left stranded, we both agreed that the place was used by previous persons who clean up and left, and as such I could not gaurnatee the place was in tip top condidtion. I only could accept his reservation if he could wait for a day to prepare for him, and that would formed part of the reeasons for accepting his reservation. In the night he went by the managers home to collect the keys base on instruction I gave to him in the night. He told me he got lost before he actually found her premises. The manager also explained to him our circumstances and handed over to him certain things for the home just to ensure his night was ok and have somewhere to sleep. The same night when he reached the home he took several photgraphed stating the place was dirty and filthy and he had to sleep on the floor and not the bed. (The bed was next to new, only four previous person had slept on the bed). He told us that he was going to visit friends and we could use the time to sort out everything. I told him to leave the keys by the security post so that the cleaners could sort out everything the following day, he left the place and was travelling ups and down with the keys. The manager had to find him, late that day. His spending money was roughly $257 US. I spent over $2000 US to replaced all that he had issues with such as bed, sofa, washing machine. The house is only 5 years old, yet he had problems with painting, fixtures and smell etc.
Two days past and he came and collected the keys after the place was sorted out, he said he was visiting friends. The keys was left at the security post after only one day of cleaning and sorting out. Three women visited the place and reported that he was not being honest base on his report. I easily sold my cleaners and other persons the items removed or replaced from my premises at 70% of their original cost. When my guest returned, he saw the place was wonderful, he was even asking about if I am willing to sell the premises, I did not entertain such conversation . Before saying thanks, my guest asked about full refunding for three nights, and I told him no. He filed report to AB saying the place was dirthy and filthy and he could not sleep at the house and had to went elsewhere to find comfort. Ofcourse AB value guest over host, as a result they subtracted 50% or $81 US for the duration my guest had problems with. My guest also told me he was going to leave a REVIEW!. And yes, that was his review. He spent the remaing 4 nights of his seven in a clean, fresh, and attractive space. AB caused us to refund him and we did, based on their policy, since then I realized there is no defence for Host.
@Ricardo741 I just read the guest's review and it appeared he did stay. Is what he said in his written review true? Tattered furnishings, place wasn't clean? If so, I don't think you can object to his review. But you might be able to get it removed due to his mentioning that he received a refund, guests aren't supposed to talk about resolutions in their reviews. And if what he said is true, I suggest you spend some time stepping up your listing, rather than objecting to 1* reviews, as you can expect more of them if the place isn't comfortable and clean.
@Ricardo741 Ah, I see. Typical entitled guest leaving a revenge review. Sorry you had that, especially on your first review. In that case, I would contact Airbnb again, and ask them to remove the review, based on him mentioning the refund in his review. It's against Airbnb review policy for a host or guest to speak to an Airbnb resolution process or outcome in their review. If you get an unhelpful or unknowledgable CS rep, just thank them for their time and call back, hopefully you'll get someone better. You might have to do this several times. look up the review rules first in Airbnb's Terms of Service, so you can quote the appropriate policy to them.
If they still won't remove the review, you can respond to it. Make your response brief, factual and professional, not all you wrote here, just that the guest was insistent on coming, even though you told him that your rules require more notice, but you accommodated his request under the understanding that the unit was not yet ready and cleaned. That many demands were made that you considered to be unreasonable but that you did your best to comply with, that he made it difficult for your staff to do their job, as he kept disappearing with the keys, etc. Condense the situation into a short paragraph and don't mention the refund.
Thanks a million, I did read AB content policy and realized that my guest did not adhere to the policy. He spoke about AB resolution in which he should not. He commented on other issues that we're of concern as well. Overall his malicious comment and review was removed from my account. My heart was heavy but now I can breathe again. Sarah I really want to give you thanks, especially sharing your experience with me and taking the time to guide me. Now I realize that this place can be very bitter, no matter how hard you try.
@Ricardo741 Congrats on getting the review removed, well done. Wishing you some nice, appreciative guests going forward.
@Ricardo741 BTW, endless posts on the hosting forum verify that guests who start out by asking you to bend your rules and policies for them, almost always turn out to be bad guests. Even more so if they're pushy and insistent about it. Rushing around trying to accommodate them doesn't lead to them being appreciative, it just leads to more demands and complaints, and they almost always leave bad reviews.
It's one thing to accommodate a guest who messages saying "Sorry, we got held up, we won't be there until 3 hours past arranged check-in time." But by and large, just stick to the rules and policies you've decided will work for you and next time you get a demanding potential guest-"I'm so sorry, but we just can't accommodate that. Best of luck finding a place that better suits your needs". If they're already in residence-"I'm sorry, that's not one of the listed amenities". "No, washing machine use isn't part of our listing description. There's a laundry just down the street. They do a nice job.".